Home / Knowledge / Horizontal Integration

What is horizontal integration in industry?

Short answer

In industry, horizontal integration means connecting process steps, sites and companies along the value chain, from the supplier through your own production to the customer. Information on demand, quantities, dates and quality flows from one stage to the next without manual steps. It is one of the three characteristics of Industrie 4.0. It does not refer to the economic term of the same name, which describes the merger of companies at the same stage.

Reading time 6 minutesEditorial team, inray Industriesoftware
Stages of a value chain from supplier to customer, connected through a continuous flow of information

Definition: horizontal integration

The recommendations for implementing the strategic initiative Industrie 4.0 (Forschungsunion and acatech, final report of 8 April 2013) describe horizontal integration through value networks as building value chains across company boundaries. The goal is coordinated collaboration from order to delivery. In practice, the term is also used within a single company, for example for connecting consecutive production steps or several plants.

Characteristic Separate stages Horizontally integrated
Passing on information By e-mail, spreadsheet or phone Through defined, machine-readable interfaces
Changes in demand Reach the next stage with a delay Are passed on to all affected stages
Inventory Buffers against uncertainty at every stage Aligned with known demand
Quality data Stays with each manufacturer Is passed on with the product
Traceability Comparing documents from several places Traceable across the chain

Why value chain stages are being connected

Electronic exchange between companies is not a new idea. The international standard ISO 9735 for EDIFACT, data interchange for administration, commerce and transport, was published in 1988. What is new is the breadth: today, production, quality and product data should flow between stages alongside orders and delivery notes.

A simple example shows how delays add up. If each of four stages in a chain passes on a change in demand only with the next daily reconciliation, it can take up to four days for the change to reach the first-tier supplier. If changes are passed on as events, the information arrives within minutes. The figures are an arithmetical example. They show why the type of connection matters more than the amount of data exchanged.

The building blocks of horizontal integration

Horizontal integration relies on standards and initiatives for exchange between stages and partners.

Building block Task Origin
Electronic data interchange (EDI) Standardised business messages such as order, delivery note and invoice EDIFACT, ISO 9735, 1988
Asset Administration Shell Standardised digital representation of an asset that can be read across company boundaries Industrial Digital Twin Association, founded in 2020 by VDMA, ZVEI, Bitkom and 20 companies
Data spaces Shared rules for controlled data exchange between companies in an industry Catena-X Automotive Network e.V., founded in 2021 by 17 companies and research institutions
Reference architecture Describes Industrie 4.0 components up to the connected world outside the plant RAMI 4.0, DIN SPEC 91345, April 2016
Integration within the company Connects systems of consecutive process steps and sites Integration patterns according to Hohpe and Woolf, Enterprise Integration Patterns, 2003

How horizontal integration works technically

Four mechanisms carry the exchange between stages.

  • Shared formats: Partners agree on message and data formats so that information can be read without rework.
  • Events instead of batches: Changes are passed on when they occur instead of being collected and transferred at fixed intervals.
  • Unique identification: Products, batches and equipment carry identifiers that stay the same across all stages or are mapped unambiguously.
  • Controlled release: Each company decides which data it passes on to whom and for what purpose.

Four steps to horizontal integration

The sequence is similar in most projects.

  1. Map the chain

    Which stages, sites and partners exchange which information today, through which path and with what delay?

  2. Define the exchange

    For each transition, it is decided which data flows in which format, at which rate and under which rules.

  3. Start with one transition

    A clearly bounded exchange, such as confirmations between two plants, is implemented and measured.

  4. Extend step by step

    Further stages and partners follow. Manual coordination is replaced deliberately by defined interfaces.

What horizontal integration is not

Four distinctions prevent false expectations.

  • Not the business strategy: In economics, horizontal integration means the merger of companies at the same stage of the value chain. That is a different topic with the same name.
  • Not vertical integration: Vertical integration connects the levels within a plant. Horizontal integration connects the stages along the chain.
  • Not open data access: Partners release only the data needed for the shared process.
  • Not purely an IT topic: Without agreements on responsibility, quality and use of the data, even the best interface remains unused.

Typical hurdles in practice

These points slow down horizontal integration projects most often.

  • Different systems: Every stage and every partner works with its own systems, formats and master data.
  • Missing internal foundation: A company that does not have its own production data in structured form cannot pass it on either.
  • Trust and confidentiality: Companies hesitate to share data on capacity, quality or costs.
  • Coordination effort: Every interface to a partner has to be agreed, tested and adapted when things change.
The honest part

Horizontal integration across company boundaries depends on both sides taking part. A single company can prepare the exchange, but it cannot force it. It is therefore usually worth connecting the transitions within your own company first, between production steps and sites.

How pronubes supports

pronubes creates the foundation that horizontal integration builds on: structured production data at every site. The product components have different tasks.

  • pronubes Edge: Edge runs in the plant and connects machines, controllers and IT systems via protocols such as OPC UA, MQTT, REST and SQL. Data from every production step is then available in a form that can be passed on to the next step, other plants or partner systems.
  • pronubes Zones: Zones maps sites, production areas and systems as a structure. Several plants can then be connected and compared according to the same principle.
  • pronubes Insights: Insights makes data flows between systems and sites visible during operation. If a confirmation is missing or an exchange is delayed, this becomes apparent before the next stage is left waiting.
Glossary
Horizontal integration
Connection of process steps, sites and companies along the value chain.
Value network
Group of companies that jointly create a product.
EDI
Electronic data interchange, standardised electronic exchange of business messages.
EDIFACT
International EDI standard for administration, commerce and transport, ISO 9735.
Asset Administration Shell
Standardised digital representation of an asset in Industrie 4.0.
Data space
Agreed framework for controlled data exchange between companies.
Traceability
Evidence of which parts, batches and steps a product was made from.
Master data
Basic data that rarely changes, such as material, customer or equipment.
Asked and answered

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between horizontal and vertical integration?

Horizontal integration connects process steps, sites and partners along the value chain. Vertical integration connects the levels within a plant, from the equipment to the ERP. Both are characteristics of Industrie 4.0 and complement each other.

Does horizontal integration only apply between companies?

No. The recommendations for Industrie 4.0 emphasise value creation across companies. In practice, the term is also used for connecting production steps and plants within one company.

What role does EDI still play today?

EDI is widely used for orders, delivery notes and invoices. For production and quality data it is often not sufficient, which is why further formats and approaches such as the Asset Administration Shell and data spaces are added.

What do data spaces such as Catena-X have to do with horizontal integration?

Data spaces create shared rules, formats and trust mechanisms for exchange between many companies in an industry. They are one way of implementing horizontal integration across company boundaries.

How do you start with horizontal integration?

With an inventory of today’s handovers between stages and sites and a clearly bounded transition within your own company. Only then is it worth extending to external partners.

Get started

Value creation does not end at the factory gate.

pronubes connects machines, controllers and systems at every site and creates the data foundation for exchange along the chain.

pronubes by inray

pronubes is a product of inray Industriesoftware GmbH. Over 30 years of industrial software from Germany. Innovative and reliable for manufacturing companies.

inray